User [gary fullett /152.202.78.116] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:03:02 EST 2000 hi gary Hey Gary hello gary good evening hi gary I want to mention please watch the gold chart in this area the 275-278 area is weekly support I sent this chart yesterday User [davep /24.147.119.114] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:04:14 EST 2000 I nibbled at these levels today for some clients gold looked interesting on intra day chart very lightly with smaller contracts for the most part gary where is smaller contract traded? chicago board of trade good i trust chicago over ny User [Peggy /206.173.174.35] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:05:20 EST 2000 evening, everyone Hey Peggy evening Peg hi peggy hi peggy Gary, I got the charts 1 1/2 hours after class. Can Kelly post them first on the site? hey dave hi lmarsh hello everyone hi peggy hi, all I think she does doesnt she if not I will ask her thanks hi dave she's due for a raise I am going to have a beginner class went over class log from last night. It was very helpful. she got a raise she works on the 2nd floor :) for us, right? from the first flooe well I can lots of emails about wyckoff class speaking just for myself :-) and so these are new traders and i suppose you pay hercummute ? oof, your getting cheaper than Jack welch! ditto, dave commute Yes I sdo sal with coffeee what a guy !!! really, a beginner class? User [amos /62.0.147.227] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:08:35 EST 2000 so I want to make sure all principles of wyckoff are imbeded in your minds peggy --don't think he saw it :) hi amos So what I will do is have this class at 7pmcst for an hour and this will lead into hi amos our nightly class I think I will do this evening, Amos hi amos hi 2 times a week gary there are only 24 hours in a day, are you superman? yes a beginners class we expect a lot from you, Gary; we're sorry you don't have a life!! tell me, why won't you be wiped out? well my day starts at 6 am and finishes at 1030 om so it is only 18 1/2 hours what time zone, Gary?? I have been working like this for 20 yrs User [mike /152.169.135.123] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:10:39 EST 2000 User [fibo /204.119.225.123] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:10:39 EST 2000 so I neer get wiped out how's your cholesterol hi fibo and mike I do take a break for 2 hours in the afternoon to walk with the dog hi central times zone I wanted to send a chart today and I didnt well i admire you , but I cant function with those hours , not married anyway but I wanted you to look at the british pound today well it is easier as Kelly and I work together hello everyone so she really knows "im working " lol hi fibo Hi fibo Hey fibo hi fibo tonight will be another fine class I will explain later but first I am mad at myself there was an easy trade today I saw it and didnt react it was in the british pound sometimes the market gives u free money in my mind if you look at the chart ( I didnt send it but follow my words and review the chart if you canpull it up if you draw on the daily chart a trendline june? abeit a negative trendline yes If you connect the 2 previous lows June, gary? it came in at the 15620 AREA YES jUNE sorry about the caps I did see this and did well at that point look at the markets reaction? stright up to 15900 area this was a great reaction from a trendline what is important to note is besides this the market did rally when a market has a strong rally or break for that matter usually the market will retraced any where from 1 -3 days if very strong or very weak 3-5 days if the market isnt as strong or weak so what happened? in this case the market rallied so we are looking for a 1 -3 day pullback since the market reacted so well off of the 15620 trendline Gary, but on the 22nd was the biggest volume day and since then and today was the third day the price went up and the volume slacked off and went to support at 15830 the actual low was 15818 do u see the volume at the low on that day the day of 15620 low ? it ws heavy volume look at the close near the high so the trendline support in which you would have seen support actually wa s great support and flew I am sorry I didnt send this chart today I meant to but that is why I say Watch reactions from support and resisatnce 14618 volume on 3/22 please look at this chart right, it bounced good of old July support yes it was an easy trade today in my opinion I was watching it go up shame on me should I send this chart tomorrow or can you all see it now? i got it do you have any questions on what I was describing I got it does anyone trade currencies here? i don't no not yet have yen have traded C$ have traded SF okay what I want to say User [gary /152.202.78.116] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:25:59 EST 2000 I lost myself I am here do you know what I mean by the overnights high and lows can u see ,me? User [gary] left forum at Wed Mar 29 21:27:01 EST 2000 after hours trading range of overnight trading yes y y no no I don't see you .lol User [gary F /152.202.78.116] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:27:27 EST 2000 can u see me wb gary y yes there u are no k do you understand what I mean by the overnight hghs and lows? y curreincies trade 24 hours a day range of overnight trading? y extreme's of after hours trading? so when u wake up in the morning check out the overnight s price action europe and asia the pit sessio at the merc will generally react to this do u have an idea why this is? arbitrage? It is because onf the CM the Cm never sleeps so if he buys support at 10 om pm he will buy support at 10 am cm so the CM will buy at 10 pm and 10 am lots of m's m and ms :) so watch the over nights high and lows the Cm never sleeps last nights high in the pound was 15956 Gary never sleeps todays high was 15980 therefore Gary is a CM :)] I want to be a cm so I never sleep :)lol therefore, gary is a CM sam I am :) sal :-) I will put this chat on the archive for tomorrow Money never sleps either should we I want to discuss another chart briefly the NASDAQ about 2 weeks ago amos mentioedn that the nasadq may have had a buying climax and that the market then broker nd was waiting for a retest well the market retested the 5 k level and fell sharply this is a market to watch carefully Please watch the reactions of of support and resistance especially horizontal ones User [sherri /209.100.190.172] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:34:30 EST 2000 that give clear support and clear resisatnce like a floor of support hi,hi , hi and a ceiling of resistance are there any questions? I dont want to start a new topic tonight I just wanted to mention those 2 markets hi sherri what I thought that we should do is go over hi sherri some terminolgy tofay hi we have mentioned prelimary support prelimary supply ect and these are pretty terms but what is there meaning and how more importantly can we profit from it as u know amos and I differ on our time frames of trading wyckoff but we both agree ( along with fibo) that wyckoff is the way to look at markets there are definitions on the web site but how do the terms that wyckoff used make us money : ) I would like to defer to amos and let him describe some of these terms to you This may be a review to some but iyt will put us all on the same level so when we discuss wyckoff we can fly with terminoglolgy sso amos if you please... two general comments before I start: 1. Difference of time frames is a very complicated issue. General Aoms Amos You will see Wyckoff behavior on different time frames--but their overall meaning to the future direction of the market will be very different. A selling climax on the 60 minutes will lead to an automatic rally. ONLY on the 60 minutes. Etc. So if you mix time frames--you can commit suicide. 2. You shoul all go to INO.Com and read some of the comments of a guy by the name eddie. Not with capital E , but small e. For example today he put a post about his day trade the address is:http://forum.ino.com/?read=140125 he is a day trader. But since we deal a lot with beans--I noticed that this guy has lived,breathed drank beans--and he is in sync with that market.It is interesting the way he reads the market. It is not Wyckoff--but some of his terminology relates. Just thought I will share good information. You will notice that I am not jealoous of ggod traders--if I see one that I respect--I do not mind thanks, will look @ it at all to listen. This is hard war and every warrior I can use on my side--I will. Now, Gary asked me to "recap" some theory of basic Wyckoff. If I bore some of you-- have a cup of coffee. :) I will probably say some new things--nevermind. If you have a question--please feel free to interrupt. The basic tenet of WYckoff appraoch to markets is that its raison detre is to transfer risk. There is risk in business and capitalistic societies found that the best way for industry and economy to brb User [sal] left forum at Wed Mar 29 21:47:25 EST 2000 amos? he must have been knocked off must have got bumped User [mike] left forum at Wed Mar 29 21:49:06 EST 2000 do you understand what he means by the transferednce of risk? User [amos /62.0.147.227] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 21:49:16 EST 2000 took me 25 minutes to get on-line tonite hope things are calm in the holy land took me awhile too sherri internet is very slow night me too I get emails from people who never can get in the CM doesn't want us to chat :-) someone is offended by risk transfer? I had to reboot the puter. risk is a bad word :) k continue sir I hate flying solo :) Ok, I shall try to continue (You lordship CM permitting) lol gore needs to "build" another internet :-) :) LOL If you accept the basic assumption that there is a reason for capital markets--then Wyckoff begins to make sense. All the talks about public doing this, commericials doing that, COT reports, what someone did or did not do on the floor, Merrill Lynch is buying 2000 here etc--is true--but superflous. Now. The next assumption is that the direction of transfer of risk is unidirectional. stop right there Very rarely do ordinary people have risk to transfer. It has to come from the producers of users of large quantities of things. unidirectional Also, the large operators of industry, by the nature of their operations will have MORE knowledge than the average participant. All the talk about the internet changing the rules of the game by making information more availaible to the average trader--is hogwash. assumption is sherri but not the fact. It may mean that the means of manipulation will have to become a little more sophisticated--but human nautre did not change in the last 5,000 years, and is not likely to change in the next decade(the decade we here want to become (or marry) millionaires.) But that is another discussion. If you accept that knowledge is not distributed equally among humans --then you have to ask yourself the following question: If I am to detect the footsteps of the forces that transfer risk, and they have to do it in a certain way that assures, more or less, their financial operations--what tools do I have to do that? Well, WYckoff said that if you observe charts intelligently, looking for specific behavior--you may be able, at times to detect the footsteps of the COmposiite Man. This is the term he coined for those more knowledeable forces that transfer their risk to us the speculators. The word speculator is not a bad wrod. It comes from Latin:speculae--"to see". Hence the word spectacles--eyeglasses. But it has earned a bad connotation. The other word: "manipulation" is also not a bad word. In order to transfer risk to us--the CM mUST manipulate us to do it. however, it is very important to all to understand--that as we come to trade with or against those more knowledgabl;e forces--we must understand that our whole and only role in the marketplace is: To take Risk !!!! We are supposed to lose. If we do not lose--then the CM loses. When the cm loses--industry fails. IBM collapses Wheat goes to $18 a bushel one day and 2 dollars the next. Havoc rules. The figures that come from the exhcanges that 90% or more of traders lose--is not an invention. It is the requirement of the market place. This is a sad statment--but unless you understand that your role in the market is to TAKE risk, i.e. to lose money--you will never make money. Any question so far? n not yet, please continue ok. interesting viewpoint, Amos I was wrong sherri, amos meant the transfer of risk is in one direction from CM to everybody else. So if you accept some of this philosophy then we can start asking some intelligent questions. thx steve 1. If the process of risk transfer is to be continuous--it must be based on some well established methodologies. Indeed. First you must understand some mob psychology. Then you must study the process (processes) of manipulation. We can go on. The reasons why so many people are trying to find a holy grail--is A) because there is none and B) because of the fact that I lost my line of thought--because I am trying to rush. Wait one second. Never mind, I will come back to it. Wyckoff made a nice shortcut. He defined one process of risk trnafer for us. When that particular process appears--it is one of the few times that we can detect the manipulative process of risk transfer by the composite man. distribution? It is crucial to understand that unless you follow the CM--your chance to make money over the long haul in the market are slim to none. I am not talkjing about individual trades--you can always be lucky and make money on individual trades. But if you continue to walk into this arena that , by definition, is supposed to take your money so the ADM, or Pillsbury, or Hershyu, of any other large company )or GOVERNMENT) are trying to unload their risk on yo0u--for their survival-- and the health of the general economy--then you are a fool. you will give your money back. Now we come to the basic definition of Wyckoff that a market can be in one of 4 phases. Accumulation, Markeuop, Distribution, Markdown. These four phases, simply say that the process of risk trnasfer can be either in the preparatory User [gary F /152.202.78.116] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:11:18 EST 2000 phase (acc, dist) or in the actual phase (markup, markdown). What is a change in price after all? It indicates that the level of supply and demand is shifting. The role of a wyckoff student is to try and identify in which phase, and in each phase at which point of the process of risk transfer---we are. The famous "wave" chart that Gary has on his site---it is not the "wave". The original Wyckoff wave is an index that Wyckoff himself invented and watched it with volume. Today, It think, SMI in Pheonix Arizona is using 5 stocks to comprise and compose that index. But that chart is simply the general behavior of the market with the 4 phases mentioned above. I must make a terrible statment. You must understand that this ideal situation--does not happen all the time. It is ONE situation when you have a good chance of identifying and detecting the action and behavior of the COmposite man. There are other situations when Wyckoff DOES not work at all. WHY? Because-if it was--then we would have the holy grail and the market will cease to exit. Is that clear? yes y yes So, why use this? its all we got y Because it is the only method, as far as I know (and I have travelled wide and high) that looks it's proven to work,.....at times there is nothing better into the actual psyciology of the internal manipulative process of the market. And when it is clear--gives you very high User [Name already in use /209.100.190.172] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:17:38 EST 2000 probability of success in following the footsteps of the CM. Many people find this very tedious. They feel they can do is as well with stochastics, moving averages, User [fibo /204.119.225.123] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:18:16 EST 2000 MACD, ADX, Bollinger bands, you name it. That is fine. But here-we are trying to "understand" the action of the market. User [Name already in use] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:19:01 EST 2000 If we read the market correctly--it is sometimes easier to follow it. Does not mean that you will make more money tho. User [sherri /209.100.190.172] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:19:18 EST 2000 If you are a floor trader- it is not easy to follow WYckoff--yet they make money. I have seen people making fortunes with the 3 minute stochastics. But it is the same with driving. We all can drive cars. Very few of us can win at Indy 500. Ok. I am going to sum up what I have said so far and I will continue with the actual ":stars" on that famous chart of 4 phases of the appocalypse tomorrow, if you are still alive. Here goes: 1. the market is an operation of risk transfer. 2. Knowledge is not distributed equally (remember "animal farm by George Orwell) 3. To transfer risk the CM must manipulate :) 4. Learning the process of manipulation is the role of a Wyckoff student 5. Once in a while when the market is going thru a risk transfer proces\ss that follows the Wyckoff dictum--we can identify the foottoesp of the CM and hopefully make money. As the Famous Vinetu the chief of the APachi tribe said: Haoook! lol For thos of you who are not familiar with Karl May--a very famous author in Europe--he wrote fantastic stories about the indians. This Vinetu guy was an awesome figure.He hardly spoke, But when he spoke--each word was wroth not gold.. but Palladium (modern joke) And when he said Haook--it meant: User [gary /152.171.25.117] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:25:53 EST 2000 "everything that has to be, or could be said was already spoken.l Any additional word is a waste of open space." I am done Do you see some markets follow wyckoff more often than the other markets, amos? another good lesson This is not a good question eric. The correct question should be: thanks amos thank you amos Do you trade when you see wyckoff action or in other cases too? Unfortunatel, because of the fact that Wyckoff is rare in the market--I tend to veer away and do stupid MA or stochastic trades and I lose! Wyckoff to me is the way to look at a market you must relieze that markets are based on fear and greed when I was on the floor and I traded wyckoff principles I always looked into peoples eyes watched market action I would see the fear or greed with the orders that enetered the pit and when the market ws cliamtic it always seemed to turn around I will share a lesson with you that I learned from a great trder he said to me that when u are about to blow out of a postion take a deep breathe and wait a minute or so if the pit that seemed like an eternity :) one important statement about monthly charts , please then if the market doesnt have a reaction back in the direction that your position is "get the hell out" 1 sec amos please the point being that if you are about to :blow out of your postion: many people are about to do the same thing so hold on a second and many times this worked sometimes the market kept going agaist me and I had a largr loss but most times it was prudent to wait that is what wyckoff mentioend about BC abd SCV SC transference of risk amos monthly charts please This weekend we should all spend some time looking at monthly and quarterly charts. If you see markets that are boviously tilted one way--it shuld give you a good indication about the expected behaviour of that market in the next month. very good point amos For example: beans. March was 500 to 5381/2. If we close on friday closer to 538--then for the month of march--regardless of planting reports and rain and whatever-- demand was more in control--this is a very significant information to bear in mind for the month of April. If the Dow closed in the middle of its quarterly chart--it will mean that supply and demand are at some balance and further sideways trading is expected. Abby cohen notwithstanding haook ! lol she called the amrket perfectly market Yes, but she is expensive u heard about mobius' comments, today, right? no tell us internet issues--many of the 500-odd--were as much as 90% over-valued!! were? ergo, tomorrow shud b another interesting day for nasdaq ever see the P/E on them??? ok, are three digits, right? yes all women are expensive :) the market stopped looking at "normal" P/E ratios long ago at least we're not cheap!!! I wanna ask a (long) wykoff question right on Peggy :-) go aheeeeeeeeeead never peggy lol yessssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss amos, except for your admitting to following other methods--with dire results--u seem to be saying we shud stand aside market dont listen to new watch market action if we can't get clear wykoff signal. right? How do I answer such a general question? It is part of you temperaemnt have heard (seen) you & gary, many times, say don't mix methods, keep wykoff pure, etc. just have trouble with idea that it cud oftenv enhance if you have live data--you can see wyckoff action all day long on the 5 min bar chart and scalp all day long even when not sending clear signal on its own I believe wyckoff happens everyday it is not the theoritical wyckoff that happens all the time but the action of wyvckoff happens all the time do u know what i mena by this? User [gary] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:42:44 EST 2000 \ davep--do you understand that it is an unanswerable question? If you are willing to devote your life to trading as you chief occupation--your whole paradigm of trading changes--and you maybe, but if i had understood it i wouldn't have asked it are looking at small time frames--and you can use WYckoff on them User [gary /152.171.25.117] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:44:20 EST 2000 You can also learn to use other tools--but the bigger question is what are you looking to define? sorry did everyone see my last comment y y y You are not looking for accumulation adn distribution, but small rallies and reactions that come to and end in a wya you can understand for over three months, now, have been reorienting my market thinking . . .haven't tested it yet it is the action that is important Not the theortical example Gary is right! good night all thanks a market is going higher intarday nite mrj nite, mrj nite nite mr J good luck to you and the market is rallying User [mrj] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:45:56 EST 2000 all of a sudden u see a spurt high volume and wide price action what does this say? bc time to liquidate a long could be buty u can see this all day long it also happens on a monthly pure wyckoff theory doesnt happen often but the action and bhavior happen ok, haven't been able to watch daily on a 5 minutes to a monthly chart watch market action price action and volume But dont mix if u get a 5 minutes bc in corn doent expect a 20 cent move down in corn there is no CAUSE on a 5 minute chart but could be a great scalp if you get a monthly BC this will gnerally lead to the largestmove because cause is built up understand just had a thought,(really i did) the waves of fiborachi(spell?) could these also be broken down with each wave, mayhaps, into wycoff action? expect a larger move on a 15 min chart than a 5 minutes one yeah, i understand all that u have waves within the wyckoff wave fiborachi,lol did you mean liborachi? fibo can u help him with :) libarachi beat me peg ok, i can't spell! lol do you mean fibonacci? or Liberace? :-) hey the way I type that was good :) Hey, no fags here :) right fibo :) fibo lol! amos be politiaclly correct :) PLEASE DON'T AMOS!!!! just be correct & he was! do u understand what I am saying about wyckoff it is the market behaivor Some of my best freinds have crooked noses. using his principles that I follow very closely watch the action with the volume.... any questions good classs tonight User [gary] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:52:26 EST 2000 thank you .....nite User [sherri] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:52:51 EST 2000 nite sherri Haoook nite sherri nite all. Thank you, Amos. nite oeggy User [gary /152.171.25.117] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:53:20 EST 2000 User [Peggy] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:53:23 EST 2000 t'care peg see ya'll next time yikes again any questions later Stevef nite steve nite User [gary] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:54:04 EST 2000 User [gary /152.171.25.117] joined forum at Wed Mar 29 22:54:16 EST 2000 well if there are no questions I think I will call it a night thank you maos amos thank you, amos and gary, good night to all nite gary thanks nite eric thanks gary nite everyone trading tomorrow makes lots of money good night User [eric] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:55:04 EST 2000 amos & gary, thank you both, especially 4 answering my last ? : ) thanks gary and amos..I'm outta here did I answer it fully davep bye all User [amos] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:55:34 EST 2000 yes fibo was quiet tinight nite amos thanks for making post with the sites fibo. I liked it User [SteveF] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:55:44 EST 2000 it was good I appreciated it as well thanks lmarsh glad you did nite all User [gary] left forum at Wed Mar 29 22:56:05 EST 2000