User [gary fullett /152.202.169.188] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:05:42 EST 2000 User [lmarsh /208.205.55.207] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:05:56 EST 2000 good evening everyone hi gary hi, gary how is everyone tonight Hello hey before we begin any questions? did anyone see anything that was wyckoff related yes, any idea why volatility of hogs gets lower for further out of money? been reading the posts, really good work not sure on that question sal matbe it has to do with prices further out the posts have been good it will be a great forum if everyone participates will do no questions>? is there anything in wyckoff to explain nasdaq? that is a great question please remember that the stock market has ben a bull market since 1982 so the uptrend has been solid for 18 yrs it will take more than a few months to make a top maybe we need a new word DG Defying Gravity that is why people get bearish when the markets break :) but the Uptrend is solidly up some stocks can be if User [sherri /209.100.190.168] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:11:32 EST 2000 in a bear market and some can be up so there can be diverencence understatement User [fibo /204.119.225.222] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:12:17 EST 2000 but as amos always says we need to piece together a puzzle hello everyone just looked at a monthly nasdeq chart, last few months have been close to vertical hi fib hi fibo hello fibo hi fibo User [Peggy /206.173.174.128] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:12:49 EST 2000 hi fibo what do we know about this puzzle the market has been stright up right lmarsh, kinda nervy Evening. Please continue what has the volume done over the last few weeks? or months even? up high, but no spike subject? nasdeq nasdaq it appears that the market with the heaviy volume and large price action maybe going thru a buying climax but this may last for months but no uptrend lines have been broken amos do you have a commnet on the nasdaq? no volume has been higher last few months than normal. what do you feel is happening with record volume and volititly? yes lmarsh no comment? r u tyring to be a plotician amos? LOL feeding on itself, stong market attracks more players politician over bought maybe / climmax building very true sal I want to say a few words about the energies k last yr when the market was at 1100 in crude I ooked at the weekly and saw a selling climax about 2 weeks later in february futures magazine had an article and I remeber it like it was yesterday it said "How low can we go " well the market was about 1 dollar from the lows when this article came out does anyone remeber this? yep, This class is relatively new but I had posted this and talked about this in class and I said that crude would hit 35 dollars a barrel in a yr everyone laughed there is a reason why I mentioedn this and it itsnt to toot my own horn but to show you how the :news: is the miost bearish on the bottom and it is bullish on the top i bot a call back around 12 and got out with $800 thinking I had defyed the experts getting back to the stock great sal should have rollled it :) should have held and held and held but the news at 1100 there was NO ONE bullish then now lets look at crude today because we trade futures not "past" ures :) you're right even the oil men neighbors in Houston were negative the news is bullish right>? but there is still some sketitism y we hear that "opec is increasing prodution" did anyone hear this? we this mentioedn3 days ago y y yes what did crude do this week? up rally sharply? why with negative news does the market rally? market dropped little Monday do you think the CM present some bearish news on the top? No Way he would sell into the new highs anticipating a BC but the news is not frantic yet no at a greed level yet so the BC isnt there yet do you see this? yes, think so are you looking at a chart? looking @ march crude didn't get charts today maybe it is going thru a BC but the news needs to be even more bullish with out negative news no charts today sherri n I am just making a few commnets go ahead thank u so... getting back to sal question about the NASDAQ there is alot of negatism in stocks thought the nasdaq is on fire so this divergence still is not at a greed level so we make higher highs as wyckoff students NEVER follow news 1 min please not that i want to , but there is never support to buy on nasdaq :) thats true so even though I know the news please dont follow it to trade it will leave u to ruins this is why I belive the Nasdaq is going higher the market and the CM's needs More bulls any questions on crude or the Nasadq? amos do you have a comment on crude? not really okay crb did anyone watch this amrket today? market? the market was up strong today y rallied good from the creek this was due in part by the energies we mntioedn last week and this week that 206 was support the market rallied over 4 point fom this level about 2 thousand dollar move !!! these sharp rallies to me are showing demand tho this index so on pullbacks to support I believ ethat this market should be bought amos commnet on the CRB? cash is strong, res at 215 in a market like this how could we place reaonable stops, or is it for bigger guys only? I think an appropiate stop in the crb is about 200 points about 1 thousand dollars no i dont think it is only for small poeple we are all small people trying to be big people :) how did you know i am 5-ft 2? I am only 5 3 so I am taller by an inch User [Peggy /206.173.174.128] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:38:58 EST 2000 any questions on the crb several popel have posted :) the crb how it is weighed did any see this? y y Glad you brought it up again, thanks y Y y print it out and keep for reference dont yell too loud amos, but for an index do you look only at its chart or also component charts sal please ask we are here to help if you can see components-much better amos you mentioned last nite about discussing mixing methods hypothetical , if your crude looked overextended, then you would wait for correction for crb? it is better to go fromthe macro to the micro do you mean index to components or monthly to daiy or both? crude does depend right now on crb but is crb rallies--other sectors will follow amos--- fibo brings up a good point about mixing methods from last night can you elaoborate Wyckoff was against mixing methods. You lose ability to identify where you went wtong wrong. simplicity is better not much more than that k amos what chart was the most useful to wyckoff longer term or shorter term daily with volume He said to use all three time frames ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Grain we mntioedn yesterday about grains and we said that the market needs to resolve itself and that 515=516 were important levels in amy beans may well today 514 was reached and the market pullback gulp amos had mentioned that if you canbut strenghth above higher highs you can be rewarded it appears to me thaT THE BEANS have developed a trading range btween the 495 and the 530 area with minor reistance at the 515-516 area and support about 500 area the market needs to show demand and good price action to move out of this range think it may trend sidways in range for another week, to build cause? I believe so Lmarsh that is a good observation but one never knows when this range will be broken todays volume seemed to be eak today was a higher high and higher low. weak so to me a break on light volume shows lack of demand but more importantly lack of supply as I beleiev that demand has shown up amos do you have a commnet on may beans? assuming it does, it will make a big count on the P&F chart. Month & 1/2 buildup? today was a higher high and higher low. User [Frank /207.230.57.35] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 21:55:59 EST 2000 hi Frank hi frank hi frank hi Frank go on amos hi Frank market should rally from here. questiions on beans? Hi Fibo Gary mr j and every one peggy marsh fibo did you have a comment on the beans>? okay does any one have any questions on the grains especially beans well yes but it is not Wyckoff...it went to fib targets today and sold off. well if it is fib related can u commnet? I sure class would like to hear just a sec thank u mr j, get that envelope yet? no Frank 1.618 of the first leg from the 500.50 low projected to 513.50 on a 15 min. chart ben waiting for it been understand then you take the next leg x 1.382 projects to 514.75 50 % ret. of the last leg down was 515 are you friendly or bearish the market? resistance on Wyckoff at 514.50 so we had a cluster of signals coming in in the same area. okay so what do u feel the market will do from here? we sold at that area and got out on close. delivery confirmation number 0304 7990 2600 3050 at www.ups.com okay i am still friendly the corn and beans thank you www.usps.com any questions on Grains A Q please? how bout anothergrain, oats... is it showing sos? or anything we talked about tonight ys peggy of course...... got it frank Please, take no offense, Fibo, but in doing what Fibo does I thinkoats and Wyckoff, is that mixing methods or another piece of the puzzle? User [eric /206.98.11.177] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 22:08:07 EST 2000 are constructive here and friendly support abot 2 censt lower it is mixing :-) since fibo is an experienced trader and has wyckodd experience it is kind of hard to unlearn important things about the market that you have studied for years. I feel that she is a value to us like everyone here is peggy, there is no one right answer but I believe she add because of her wyckff backround wyckoff used the 50 percent retracement are you saying that as beginners, we should be purists for the time being? as a mjor tool for his work to me all of the old masters studied the same charts to come to their analysis of the markets one should always follow wyckoff as a urist if possible they just called the same point on a chart a different name. but that is probably impossible I agree with that fibo that is correct fibo I believe we learn from people that have experience and knowledge fibo is right that helps. Thank you, all. Ken roberts larry williams they took th old masters charts and renamed them yes they didnt reinvent the wheel they marketed it better they just repackaged it yes sir well any other questions? o. j. oj is guilty i think Wyckoff is one of the most important things of any method. next question lol lol I fuly agreee Oj had good support athe 8330 area yesterday the market took out that support by 80 points and today Wyckof method originated from tape reading, Gann was a mathamatical genius, the market closed about resistance longer term I am friendly and they both did the same thing longer termmeaning ? correct frank well I dont know if they did the same thing though frank wyckoff didnt do alot with math over the next few months at least oj has had two large volume days in feb and held support right? I'm fairly new @ wycoff, but I think fibo is right about it being one of most important methods. they did both went to ranges of accumulation or distribution, just different time frames correct sal very good wycoff, that is what do u mean differnt time frame? gotta go folks, good trades tomorrow,...planning paper trades as well, nite. nite lmarsh nite, Marsh nite marsh so with my wheaies , cocoa, and ham, shall we add juice to breakfst soon? lol I did want to mention a chart that tested contract lows and reacted nicely today User [lmarsh] left forum at Wed Mar 01 22:17:18 EST 2000 Breakfast of Champions!! it is a chart wehavent talked about recently it is rice month? that was my next ? sal maybe juice is what is missing Lol may I think rice can be bouight with a stop under the lows does rice respond to cotton? Wycof was a tape reader read the market directly, and gann a more or less seasonal, math ratio time trader, i think Gann read the tape too but never told anyone what was ganns time frame? like amos said it is the secret of the market what is Gann read the tape and that is how he got his basics, then he put his mathimatical genius to work volume Gann saw numbers the way we can see the sky amos do u have a comment ongann was a genius like u just like you amos no so did buffet and rockerfellow or is it learned intuition accompanied by personal strengths? I think experience or learn all the complexities to come back to simplcicity in watching amrkets is very critical Wyckoff interviewd Gann when he made all of those trades that everyone talks about yes the expresion KISS is very treu keep it simple stupid as I get more expeirnced you can only be intuitional about that with which you work what I learn is I get nformation overload amen on overload but one must always follow markets study study study organization is the answer to information over load I think the hardest job in making money is after you make decision Gann site: http://www.solarmatrix.com/gann/paylist.htm on weather to buy or to sell is to be true to yourself and say to yourself" Do i think I m right my postion by market action and volume if so hold your postion if Not GET OUT if the market action with volume isnt what u expect when you enter the market get out this is critical everyone I mean everyone is guily of this we fight the amrket market we shouldnt in thoery thanks amos,there is one on traders club also if we are not right Get out quickly your first loss os your best loss had lots of best losses:) being sensative like tis to market si critical and only comes this experience exprience will make u run faste faster running fast is good!!!!! questions on what I said? and on class tonight? Thank Kelly for getting the transcripts out so quickly. I get to reread them on my lunch hour!! may i ask a semi fundamental ? just out of curiousity? I try to have her get them out by 7am the next morning I hope they help y yes sal of course u may ask anyhting User [Randy /204.246.241.52] joined forum at Wed Mar 01 22:31:35 EST 2000 hi Randy hi I was told rice went up cause cotton is going up and therefore more acreage will go to cotton and less to rice hi randy hows payroll lol yiks done! thank goodness is there a spread there? be care full with beans there is a whole river between 514 and 540 I wuld nt want to touch that one wyckoff wise sal Not that I know of what do u mean Frank? a whole river>? well I need to make several phone calls tonight before I get to bed I will see all of you tomorrow night I will be send ingxome charts too nite gary thanks nite gary some charts I'm outta here, also. Nite all. thank you all... nite good night see you tomorrow nite Peggy thank you nite peggy but all of you can stay and chat User [amos] left forum at Wed Mar 01 22:34:47 EST 2000 User [Peggy] left forum at Wed Mar 01 22:34:49 EST 2000 nite peggy good night User [gary fullett] left forum at Wed Mar 01 22:34:57 EST 2000